Teen Queen Madness: The Wild Card

Before we can start the agonizing process of creating our brackets (it’s like a real Sophie’s choice up in here), we need to pick our final contender for Teen Queen. Your top three suggestions are below! Will the Wild Card be:

Bianca Lawson, who is already the queen of eternal youth,

Tatyana Ali, who as one reader put, is the “Fresh Princess of our hearts”,

(Preach it, sister.)

or Shiri Appleby, the original Roswell comeback kid who charmed not only us humans, but some pretty cool aliens.

Who will be going up against Sarah Michelle Geller? Get your votes in by Saturday at 11:59 p.m. CST!