Teen Queen Madness: CosmoGirl, Round One

Welcome back to Teen Queen Madness! Closing out Round One of voting is the CosmoGirl bracket, named after the magazine near and dear to Teen Mandy W.’s heart. (I actually still owned a bunch of copies until I moved twice in under two years and promptly relinquished my hoarding ways.)

Let’s check out the bracket:

And now let the voting commence for our cover girls!

(1) Molly Ringwald vs. (16) Maisie Williams

Arya Stark might know her way around a fight, but no one’s as Pretty In Pink as Molly.

(8) Anne Hathaway vs. (9) Danielle Fishel

Topanga may have ruled over Boy Meets World, but Mia Thermopolis is a literal princess!

(5) Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen vs. (12) Rachel Bilson

As much as I love Summer Roberts, it’s freaking Mary-Kate and Ashley.

(4) Emma Stone vs. (13) Dakota Fanning

Emma’s got a pocket, got a pocketful of sunshine, and she’s taking aim at sparkly vampire Dakota.

(6) Melissa Joan Hart vs. (11) Sophia Bush

Clarissa Darling and Sabrina Spellman vs. Brooke Penelope Davis?! More like woes over foes.

(3) Hilary Duff vs. (14) Hailee Steinfeld

In this battle of actor-singer hyphenates, I have to go with the one whose concert tee I still own. (OK, I still hoard some things.) Will Hailee be “So Yesterday”, or will Hilary be pushed to The Edge of Seveenteen CosmoGirl?

(7) Nina Dobrev vs. (10) America Ferrera

Two heroines of adaptations that involve a lot of writing. (There’s probably a better way to describe this tenuous commonality, but it’s not happening because I’m still trying to figure out how to name-drop Teen Mom Mia ANDDDDD DONE.)

(2) Claire Danes vs. (15) Kiernan Shipka

Juliet or (another) Sabrina? Maybe these two can bond over playing characters with extreme boyfriend trubs.

Polls close this Saturday at 11:59pm Central, with results posted on Sunday. So which queens are you loyal to? Let us know in the comments below!